![]() |
Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Which is the best gold coin for your money?
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
I'm surprised so many here think Maples are better for your money than Krugerrands. The premium is about 7 bucks higher on Maples. When gold hits $1200, will the premium on Maples be $14 higher than the premium on K-rands?
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
The cheapest one.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
You can't beat pure 999.9999 gold.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
As for the Kruggerand, it can't be traded in some countries possibly because of its 'Apartheid' associations. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Just to be clear, the poll asks which one is better for your money. Everyone here is from different places and different premiums exist in different markets.
With that in mind, I am assuming that they are all priced the same for this poll. And if that is true, give me all maples. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
If they're all priced the same, I'd change my vote to the Philharmoniker. Krugs are just plain boring, Maple Leafs scratch too easily, Gold Eagles are American, but Phils are simply beautiful.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
I think Krugs are the best bang for the buck when things get tight and premiums shrink. They are pre-shrunk. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
I've bought a good half of my precious metals during day trips over the border into Canada and found out that you have to pay tax on anything that's not .999, so Krugs and Eagles are right out on the gold side of things in Canada or for those of us who occasionally buy in Canada during our business travels. I voted for maples. Other than gold bars, they're what I can get for closest to spot and I keep them safe where they won't get scratched.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Basic coin,of course its Kruger for value and salability I would think.
Spuds:sheep: |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
For Americans the Eagle could be the best - on eagles you do not have to pay taxes for any gains and you do on the others.. That is if you report your buys and sells...
http://goldprice.org/buying-gold/200...free-gold.html |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
I like sovereigns for value and the Lunar dragons and snakes for looks.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
I voted Krug with a Maple being a very close second.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Panda. It is super-pretty, I don't care about the premium (I don't count pennies), and the future might well belong to China. Will make Pandas super-recogniceable and desirable.
For pure bang for buck obviously coins make little sense. Pamp Suisse bars are cheaper per ounce and very liquid. Otherwise just get the cheapest you can. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
In the poll, maples get my vote :clap2: |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
IMO
Best Buy: British Sovereigns= price, size, well know currency. Krugerands a close 2nd. Favorite Coin: U.S. 5$ Indian. Disapointment: Pandas, sorry they just didn't do much for me. Hopeful: New U.S. Indian Head/Buffalo .9999 I would buy Maples again before Eagles (unless the tax break is confirmed). 13's My Lucky Number Prag |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
POLL:
Thanks for the replies. Currently the Krugerrand is the clear leader with 19 out of 46 votes. Although the difference in purity in the coins listed - .9167, .917, .9999 - doesn't seem to count for much now in most people's thinking, what I'm wondering is whether or not it might become very significant if the price of gold really rockets, say, into the thousands. Doesn't the spot price of gold imply a certain purity level? :confused: |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
I think that the difference between .917 and .9999 will come into play more the higher gold prices go. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
From my understanding the coins that are less than .999 still contain an ounce of gold, but also contain some other metal to make them stronger.
I do find that somewhat attractive. While I don't handle my gold at all, I do see how if we did use gold as money again, we'd want it to actually change hands. Eages and Krugs woulds certainly be better to circulate than Maples, Pandas or Philharmonics. It really depends on what the buyer wants to do with the coin. If it's just for commerce, they likely would keep it as is. If they're going to melt it down, I assume there's a process for seperating out the alloy that might make the pure coins more desirable. It's really a tough call about how a future buying might react to different purities in all the various future possibilities. I'm going to stick with maples for now, but in the future I might move into a variety of coins. I think the premium isn't much of a big deal. While people talk about gold being at a 20+ year high, if you adjust for inflation, the January 1980 price would actually be about 2000, not 850. We're currently at about 335 in 1980s dollars. There's still a long way to go up for both gold and silver before we reach historic highs. All we're doing now is catching up with what the prices should have been had not the central banks of the western world sold so much. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
I get the feeling that a .917 coin means that you are getting a mix of gold plus copper or whatever that totals 1 Troy oz in weight. In other words, that you are getting .083 less actual gold than with a .9999 coin. Has anyone actually checked this out? |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
Current prices at NW Territorial Mint are: Krugerrand (.917) $607.60 Eagle (.9167) $622.60 Maple (.9999) $621.60 Vienna (.9999) $660.20 Not sure what to make of this except that the Krugerrand looks like the best buy right now. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Quote:
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Krugerrands are still at the top of my holdings list in AU coins......easy to buy, sell, trade, and a good supply usually available. Even with the newer issues, Maples, Eagles, Phillies, etc., the Krugerrand is still the most widely held one ounce gold coin in the world and still considered the "universal currency" with no actual face value, but a floating "official" value pegged to the price of gold.
Concerning alloyed coins, all one ounce gold coins contain precisely one ounce of gold, PLUS the added alloy. 90% gold coins weigh a total of 1.1111 troy ounces for those with one ounce of gold content, and 22 karat (.9167 fine such as the Krugerrand or Gold Eagles) weigh a total of 1.0909 ounces including their one ounce of gold PLUS the alloy. Krugerrands are alloyed only with pure copper, while the Eagles are alloyed with a combination of copper and silver, causing the difference in their respective colors. Pure gold, .999 or .9999, has a color mystique all it's own. The golden "glow" of pure cast gold bars makes most coins pale in comparison. But one of the reasons that so many jewelers and refiners really prefer Krugerrands is their low buy/sell spreads, availability at close to spot market prices, and the fact that removing only copper alloy from gold is a much more simple chemical process than removing both silver and copper by electrolysis. When only copper is involved, it's simply a matter of using one type of acid to remove the copper, leaving behind pure gold "sludge" to be melted back into fine gold if needed. But for the most part, gold coin "trade units", especially in one ounce increments, are best left in their coin form for trade purposes. Here is a repost of an earlier article I wrote on Krugerrands. Notice the prices mentioned........ :musicus: ----------------------- Krugerrands - Still the "Universal Money" Sitting at the computer late into the night over the past weekend, and catching up on the usual PM forums that I try to follow on a daily basis, I realized that I had been at this gold and silver game for alot of years. I remember my first 1964 Kennedy half dollar like it was yesterday, brought home to me by a friend of my mom's sometime in early '64. I also remember getting my "weekly allowance" in the form of standing liberty quarters or walking liberty halves, though the Washingtons and Franklins were the current production models at the time, helping to date myself a little more precisely. Those of us who have followed the metals since the re-legalization of private gold ownership in 1974 remember fondly the first Krugerrand coins to hit the markets, and the simplicity they provided in determining ounce-related holdings rather than having to go through the routine of adding, subtracting, and multiplying odd-sized fractional coins such as the Sovereigns and European ".1867 standard" pieces, Coronas, Pesos, and so on. The Krugerrands were really the first to employ the ounce standard as a way of putting gold bullion coin investment front and center. Here we are today, some 37 years after the introduction of the original Krugerrand, and even with the later introduction of other popular bullion issues such as the Maple Leaf and U.S. Gold Eagle, the Krugerrand remains to this day what is probably the most recognized "Universal Currency" in the form of a gold coin, much as the U.S. Dollar remains the most recognized paper currency counterpart. Few realize that the Krugerrand was originally issued as just that - a "Universal Currency", and thus the lack of any monetary "value" being placed on the coin itself, other than its gold content. In effect, the Krugerrand has a floating value based on the intrinsic value of the material it is composed of, and not the artificial decree (fiat) of some government. Anywhere you go in the world, you can exchange a gold Krugerrand for whatever happens to be the local currency at the time. Krugerrands, even after their U.S. "apartied ban" of the '80s, remain to this day as probably the most recognizable of all the ounce-standard gold bullion coins. Anyone who keeps up with valuations and market quotes on a timely basis realizes also that the Krugerrand remains as one of the best values in gold bullion coins. While the Canadian Maple Leaf, U.S. Gold Eagle, and other popular issues may command upward of $20-$25 premiums in this current escalating market, Krugerrands can generally still be bought on buy/sell spreads of less than $5 per coin, and in some cases, if you do some shopping around on both the buy and sell sides, you might even manage to cut those spreads by a couple of more dollars. One of the larger west coast dealers I normally do business with quotes Krugerrands at $5 over spot, while another mid-south dealer I frequently work with is paying $2.50 over spot, giving a $2.50 spread by using what I like to call the "dealer-kiting" process. I suppose there are some of us who buy those "prettier coins" due to a personal preferrence in design, making it easier to hold on to the coins that we like. Lord knows the Krugerrand is no artistic masterpiece. But maybe the willingness to buy "those ugly coins" has an advantage in other ways, perhaps making it easier for some of us to "let go" when the best time comes to sell or trade out of our position. The lower premium spread is no doubt another incentive, since for many of us, the most gold at the least cost is really our first objective. And as of now, the Krugerrand still provides some of those advantages while overall premiums seem to be rising on most all other bullion related gold. When all is said and done, premiums will matter little after a substantial rise in the market, but those few extra ounces of metal might. Personally, I would rather go to my dealer and walk out with 52 Krugerrands than 49 or 50 Eagles or Maple Leafs for the same money. The same carries over into the silver market as well. Junk 90% silver bags are currently selling at barely (3 or 4 cents) over spot in comparison to premiums of 40 cents to $1.75 or more on Silver Eagles, rounds, and fine bars. One dealer was recently unloading 40% silver half dollar bags at 20 cents UNDER silver spot. Again, a matter of getting the most value for your money. -------------------------------------------------------------------- Premiums have risen several dollars on Krugerrands since this was originally written, due to increased interest in the gold bullion markets. Nevertheless, Krugerrands still carry one of the lowest buy/sell spreads of any of the one ounce gold bullion coins. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Very helpful posts. Thanks.
I guess now we know why the Krugerrand is leading the poll. Besides being a bargain in terms of its premium, it's not such a bad-looking coin as some seem to think. |
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
I thin the Euro version of the Philharmonic is awesome but they are just too hard to get around here.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
One more thing, you forgot to put Chinese Panda's in the poll. I know a few people that prefer them over anything else.
|
Re: Which is the best gold coin for your money?
Maples. Just in case I need to cross the northern border to escape anarchy.
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:17 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright = None use it and Link to GIM